PCIe latency reduction for storage IP on FPGA

PCIe latency reduction for storage IP on FPGA

We recommend treating FPGA PCIe latency as a measurement question before changing the design. Define the transaction and measurement boundaries, then assess pipeline-operator delay and buffer-related delay separately. This gives the design review a clear basis for comparing changes against the requirements that matter.

The short answer

To reduce FPGA PCIe latency in a storage design, first define the transaction, the measurement start and end points, the workload, and the latency target. Compare candidate configurations under the same conditions, and label each result as a design target, simulation result, or hardware measurement. Then assess buffer capacity and FIFO timing against the target. A reduction in buffer memory is not, by itself, evidence of lower latency.

We recommend changing one design variable at a time where practical. Keep the workload and measurement boundaries consistent, so the comparison addresses the implementation change rather than a change in how the result was obtained. Treat routing assumptions and memory-access techniques as separate questions, and choose the configuration whose measured result meets the design’s stated requirements.

Where does latency accumulate across an FPGA storage interface?

Latency can include the fixed delay of pipeline operators and additional delay when downstream processing stalls and buffers fill. A latency tutorial explains that slow downstream processing can fill buffers and increase delay beyond the fixed delay of pipeline operators.

For a storage-interface review, we recommend keeping those contributors distinct. Record pipeline-operator delay separately from delay associated with buffers filling during a downstream stall. If the two are combined into one total, it becomes harder to tell which part of the path a proposed change is intended to address.

Use a stage-by-stage record rather than relying on a single latency figure. List the pipeline operators in the path, then note the measurement boundaries and conditions for each result. Where the design offers comparable observation points, use them consistently. This is a review method, not a claim that every FPGA interface exposes a particular counter, timestamp, or measurement point.

Keep conclusions about the design tied to measurements from that design. The tutorial explains how a downstream stall can add delay; it does not provide a numeric delay or a result for a particular FPGA storage implementation. We recommend using the distinction to frame the investigation, not to assume that either contributor dominates before the design has been assessed.

How does pipeline depth affect the latency budget?

Pipeline depth should be treated as a design variable, not as a standalone predictor of the result. We recommend comparing candidate implementations with the same latency boundaries and acceptance criteria.

First, define what begins and ends the measurement, then state which requirements each candidate must meet. Keep the transaction definition and measurement setup consistent while comparing pipeline configurations. That makes the result relevant to a specific engineering decision rather than to a change in the test conditions.

Candidate How to assess it
Shallower pipeline Keep it in consideration if its measured result meets the design’s stated requirements.
Deeper pipeline Choose it when the same comparison shows that it is needed to meet a stated requirement.

For each candidate, record the pipeline configuration, transaction definition, measurement boundaries, and acceptance criterion. We recommend choosing from that comparison rather than from stage count alone. If requirements pull the decision in different directions, state which requirement each candidate meets or misses instead of reducing the decision to an unexplained pass-or-fail label.

Which memory-access patterns suit latency-sensitive transfers?

For FPGA kernels with regular access patterns, static access scheduling and data reuse are approaches to consider for hiding memory latency. A dissertation on FPGA memory-interface generation describes a methodology for generating a custom memory interface and associated DMA controller for kernels with regular access patterns, including those features.

We recommend making the access pattern explicit before discussing these techniques. For a regular pattern, consider whether static scheduling and data reuse belong in the design approach. Keep that design discussion distinct from any claim about PCIe latency: the dissertation describes a methodology and its features, not a measured PCIe-storage latency result.

A useful review record identifies the pattern under consideration, whether static access scheduling is part of the proposed approach, and whether data reuse is being considered. Those points help frame the design choice without turning the cited methodology into a performance claim for a different implementation. If the question is whether a storage design reduces PCIe latency, assess that result separately for the design under review.

What should system designers examine in root-complex routing?

System designers should compare the routing plan with the assumptions recorded for storage-IP integration, then decide which choices are fixed and which remain open. We recommend treating a mismatch as a question to resolve, not as proof that routing explains the latency under review.

Start by writing down the route under consideration and the assumptions that accompany it. Separate specified choices from choices still open to the integrator. Then connect each item to the latency objective it is meant to support. This keeps the discussion focused on the design decision instead of treating an assumption as a measured cause.

  • Which routing choices are specified by the system design?
  • Which choices remain open to the integrator?
  • Which routing assumptions are recorded for the storage-IP integration?
  • What latency objective should guide the discussion?
  • Which other design decisions will stay unchanged during the review?

If the route is already specified, we recommend checking whether the integration assumptions match that plan. If alternatives remain open, document the basis for the choice before changing other design decisions. Keep the comparison focused on routing and the stated latency objective, rather than changing several questions at once.

An engineer positions a probe beside the connector on an FPGA storage board.

How should latency be measured under representative workloads?

We recommend measuring latency with a workload that matches the intended storage task, while stating the timing boundaries and explaining how the results are summarized. A result is more useful for a design choice when the workload and the measurement method are clear.

Begin by defining what starts and ends the measurement. For example, choose an identifiable request at the input to the measured path and a completion at its output, then use those same boundaries for every comparison. Record the transaction being measured alongside the result. Without a clear boundary, it is difficult to know what the reported latency includes.

Build the workload profile from the target application or its specification. Record the request-size mix, concurrency, read/write mix, and any transitions between operating phases. If the application has distinct modes, keep their results separate rather than combining them under one representative label. We recommend calling a workload representative only when its profile corresponds to the intended application; otherwise, label it as a test profile.

For a comparison, keep the FPGA image, PCIe setup, host configuration, and storage target constant where practical. If the purpose is to compare configurations, change one element at a time where practical and identify any changes made together. Retain the results for each run, and report a central latency measure alongside a measure that describes the higher-latency portion of the results. Avoid presenting an average alone when the distribution matters to the decision.

Include the workload profile, measurement boundaries, configuration, and summary method with each result. We recommend keeping unlike workload profiles separate, so the design team can judge each result against the task it represents rather than relying on one headline figure.

How should latency targets shape storage-IP integration choices?

Set the latency target first, then assess buffer capacity and FIFO timing against it. A proposed PCIe DMA design reported a 97.6% reduction in required FPGA buffer memory, from 24.10 MB to 0.56 MB.

We recommend treating that result as a resource-budget reference, not as evidence that a latency target has been met. It concerns required buffer memory for the proposed design; it is not a latency result or a promised saving for another FPGA design. Keep that distinction clear when using the result to frame an integration discussion.

Define the target in terms the implementation review can use: the operation it applies to, its start and end points, and the maximum value the design must meet. Keep this definition alongside the IP configuration under consideration. Then assess buffer capacity and FIFO timing as distinct decision variables, recording how each configuration relates to the same target.

If a setting changes, reassess the choice against the unchanged requirement instead of assuming that a larger or smaller buffer is inherently preferable. When multiple candidates meet the target, we recommend using the remaining implementation constraints to choose between them. Do not infer a latency advantage from a buffer-memory result alone.

When is a PCIe storage interface the wrong fit?

A PCIe storage interface is the wrong fit when it serves no explicit system requirement or cannot be reconciled with the project’s constraints. We recommend retaining it only when the design has a clear reason for choosing it.

Write down the role the storage interface must serve, then separate that need from preferences carried over from an earlier architecture. If familiarity with PCIe is the main rationale, identify the current product requirement that supports the choice. Familiarity alone is not a sufficient design reason.

List the project constraints that shape the decision, such as platform, schedule, or validation requirements, and assess the interface against them. If the rationale depends on an assumption the team has not agreed to, mark it as unresolved rather than treating PCIe as the default.

Our recommendation is to retain PCIe when the design has an explicit reason for it and the project constraints support that choice. Otherwise, reopen the interface decision and assess the candidates against the same written requirements.

In summary

We recommend defining the transaction, measurement boundaries, workload profile, and latency target before revising the implementation. Compare candidates under consistent conditions, change one design variable at a time where practical, and keep unlike workload profiles separate. Use results tied to the stated requirement to guide the integration choice. If no candidate meets it, revisit the requirements and the design options.

Sources

How we wrote this article

The sources are listed at the end of the article. Where we cite none, it is our opinion, and we write it as such.

This article gives buying criteria and our point of view. It does not replace a professional’s advice on a specific situation.

It is published by Logic Design Solutions, which therefore has an interest in the subject.

Sources
  1. Latency | Basler, docs.baslerweb.com
  2. “MEMORY INTERFACE SYNTHESIS FOR FPGA-BASED COMPUTING” by Zheming Jin, scholarcommons.sc.edu
  3. A resource and timing optimized PCIe DMA architecture using FPGA internal data buffer, jstage.jst.go.jp